Mama Renie's Pizza - Nelsonvillle

Enjoy delicious thin-crust pizza, cheesy breadsticks, flavorful subs, and more at Mama Renie's Pizza in Nelsonville. Friendly staff, great atmosphere, and a menu packed with your favorites await. Call us today!

Welcome to Mama Renie's Pizza - Nelsonvillle

Experience the finest dining

Mama Renie's Pizza - Nelsonvillle
Mama Renie's Pizza - Nelsonvillle
Mama Renie's Pizza - Nelsonvillle
Mama Renie's Pizza - Nelsonvillle

Welcome to Mama Renie's Pizza, a local gem in the heart of Nelsonville. Nestled at 23 Public Square, this inviting pizzeria captures the essence of community with its warm atmosphere and friendly staff. Known for its gourmet pizzas and hearty subs, Mama Renie's gets locals talking. The restaurant features a vibrant decor that reflects the charm of Nelsonville, making it a perfect spot for a family dinner or a quick bite with friends.

With a focus on quality ingredients, Mama Renie's prepares each dish with care and passion. Whether craving a classic Meat Lovers pizza or a unique Chicken Bacon Ranch, each option delights the taste buds. The easy-to-reach location and excellent service make this pizzeria a beloved hub for locals and visitors alike.

Mama Renie's Pizza stands out with its extensive menu that caters to all cravings. With 47 different dishes, variety is the name of the game here. Pizza enthusiasts will love the thin, crispy crust topped with fresh ingredients, including popular choices like BBQ Chicken and Hawaiian pizza. Subs are another highlight; sink your teeth into the ribeye or buffalo chicken sub for a filling treat.

On top of that, the cheesy breadsticks are a must-have, perfect for sharing or enjoying solo. Specials like the Spicy Pepperoni Pizza Sub and the offer of 2 large, 2 topping pies with 6 breadsticks deliver unbeatable value. The restaurant also serves fresh salads and delicious pasta dishes, ensuring there’s something for everyone. The cozy atmosphere, combined with awesome staff, keeps patrons coming back for more.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

23 Public Square, Nelsonville, OH 45764, United States

Phone

+1 740-753-2116

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Mama Renie's Pizza - Nelsonvillle
Mama Renie's Pizza - Nelsonvillle
Mama Renie's Pizza - Nelsonvillle
Mama Renie's Pizza - Nelsonvillle

Mama Renie's Pizza is not just a place to eat; it’s a community gathering spot where flavors and friendships flourish. The restaurant finds its roots in Nelsonville, a town rich in history, known for its vibrant arts scene and beautiful landscapes. Mama Renie's has embraced the local culture, making it a favorite among residents and visitors alike. The pizza shop takes pride in offering a diverse menu featuring gourmet pizzas, subs, pasta, and salads.

Mama Renie's has gained a reputation for its high-quality ingredients and commitment to flavor. Each pizza is crafted with a unique blend of sauces, cheeses, and toppings, catering to various tastes. Subs are generously filled, ensuring no one leaves hungry. The chefs constantly innovate, introducing new specials and limited-time offers that excite loyal patrons. Daily specials keep things fresh and encourage new flavor experiences. Not only does Mama Renie's focus on food, but it also embraces customer service. The staff always greets guests with a smile, creating a warm and welcoming environment. This attention to detail enhances the dining experience, making it memorable.

Mama Renie's Pizza - Nelsonvillle

The exterior of Mama Renie's Pizza draws you in with its quaint storefront located right on Public Square. The building showcases classic architecture, matching the historical feel of Nelsonville. Outdoor seating options invite guests to enjoy their meals while soaking up the local atmosphere. The vibrant signage and inviting colors hint at the delicious offerings inside, while the lively hum of conversation from the diners adds to the charm. This pizzeria embraces a laid-back vibe, perfect for a casual dining experience with family or friends. Whether seated indoors or outside, every meal at Mama Renie's becomes a cherished memory.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • Monday11 AM-9:30 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-9:30 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-9:30 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9:30 PM
  • Friday11 AM-10 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-10 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

Absolutely fantastic food, friendly, fast service & very fair prices! If you're in the Nelsonville area, do yourself a huge favor and eat here!!! A+++

R
Rebecca C.

Came to Hocking Hills for the weekend. We needed to hit up the grocery store (shoutout to the Nelsonville Krogers) and decided to stop for pizza on the way back to our cabin. We got a 14" pie with three toppings. It was more than enough food for my wife and I with a bagged salad from the grocery store. It was so so good! I haven't had a circle pizza cut into squares in a long time. The crust was tender and had a great crunch. The sauce was flavorful. The toppings seemed fresh. If we are ever out this way again, I would totally get pizza again!

A
Andrea A.

They guys working here were wonderful they let us come in on a very snowy night. The service was wonderful and the pizza was very good I recommend 100 percent..

K
Kristan B.

My man and I ate there tonight. It was a wonderful atmosphere, GREAT FOOD, and even better service. We are from out of state and we will be back!

P
Penelope T.

First time getting Mama Renies pizza and I will say we are hooked. Wed been searching for a pizza shop and this is the one!

J
Jessica W.

The pizza is delicious and the owner was super nice! Probably one of the best pizza's I've had!

O
Olivia H.